Preview of my most recent findings

I continue to do a lot of reading on early Christianity, now focusing on the datings of Christian scriptures and interpreting the Gospel According to Mark. I have been slow to write up my thoughts because they are still jelling. However, I can give you a preview of how they are shaping up. My tentative views follow.

Mark’s gospel provides support for the hypothesis that Jesus was a real person. His writing’s genre is the ancient bios, which provides a relatively brief portrait of the life of some known figure. That figure could be a real historical person or a legendary figure. As Mark clearly places Jesus in the early first century, and not in times remote to his audience, most likely that audience knew Jesus had lived close to their time, and thus was a real person.

I also find it plausible Jesus proclaimed the imminent inauguration of the rulership of God, an expectation that was widely held at the time, and that he performed public exorcisms and healings, which gained him attention for his preaching. There have been people who claim powers over spirits and the ability to heal across thousands of years and all around the globe, so this is not a radical claim to make about someone.

As for other miracles, including walking on water, multiplying loaves and fishes, the transfiguration, and the resurrection, I noticed that these never occur in public but always in private to his immediate followers. That makes these claims more subject to suspicion as the invention of Mark or his sources. They would not have been events of general public knowledge.

Major themes in his gospel are tensions around Jesus’ identity and misunderstandings about the role of the Messiah. These portray Jesus as not want to claim honor for himself by professing he is the Messiah or to raise expectations for what he will do as the Messiah, who was expected to rule Israel with the authority of God. His clear admission to being the Messiah at his questioning by the chief priests model for Mark’s audience the profession of Jesus as Christ when questioned, and the acceptance of suffering and possibly death for professing this. This is a clue that Mark was writing in response to a time of persecution for confessing Jesus as Christ, possibly in Rome shortly after the persecution by the emperor Nero in 64-65 C.E.

Another prominent theme is the predicted destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem along with the collapse of the priestly governance of Judea, which happened at the end of the general Jewish rebellion against Rome in 70 C.E. This suggests a date for the gospel of the early 70s or shortly after.

It’s clear the Gospel According to Matthew copied from Mark while adding large blocks of sayings attributed to Jesus. This shows two things: Matthew regards Mark is largely reliable in his general picture of Jesus, but he also had independent knowledge of things Jesus had said. This again supports the hypothesis that Jesus was a real person.

I think Matthew was written very soon after Mark, and both of them before Josephus published his Antiquities of the Jews about 94 C.E. My working hypothesis about Jospehus’ famous paragraph about Jesus is that he was paraphrasing what he learned from Matthew’s gospel, probably indirectly rather than having a copy in front of him. If I am right, Mark and Matthew came before 94 and after the Jewish revolt, so in the 70s or 80s of the first century. The Gospel According to Luke, however, copies from Mark, Matthew, and Josephus, and thus I date it to the early first century.

I am still looking into the dating of Paul’s epistles, but more and more I am persuaded that these read more like documents from the second rather than the first century. The heavy focus on philosophical/theological exposition and tensions between the Jewish Law and Christianity are both characteristic of writers in the second century.

Well, that’s it for now. I hope to start writing up my analysis of Mark’s gospel very soon.